I spent four years as an active brother in the Kappa Sigma Fraternity, Lambda Sigma Chapter at James Madison University. I made bonds that will last a lifetime, some on the deepest of levels. It’s proven to be one of the most consequential decisions of my life.
It was everything the 80s were: loud, confusing, euphoric, conflicted. Lots of shiny day-glo, acid-washed, hair-gelled, synthesized fun. Thanks to Kappa Sig I learned much, lessons that I conjure on the daily. Sometimes fondly, sometimes with a wince. Sometimes wondering how I am still alive.
There was leadership and governance, camaraderie, honor, community, trust and friendship. Competition. Charity. Humility. Avarice. Racism and homophobia. Misogyny. Bodily functions, odors, casual nudity, purposeful nudity and some real freaky-deakies. Prigs, pies and rednecks, rockstars, sports stars, Reaganites and Prince wannabes, There was chew, smokes, ledge beers, tequila shots and hairy buffaloes, medicinal shampoos, cheap cologne, lines, rails, tabs, hits, boomers, inhalants and activities that only started after 2AM.
Ready for some 80s? If not, turn back now. Serious.

This was five years after “Animal House.” I saw it when I was in the 8th grade. The film was a boon for the Greek system: recruitment soared. It was also a curse: chivalry and decorum suffered. Gratuitous 70/80s-style indulgence and male chauvinism saw an opening and went for it. Through the lens of the time, it made sense and was pretty awesome. No apologies. Okay a few.
Until recently–and honestly until this 60|60 exercise–I didn’t fully appreciate the value of my Kappa Sigma experience. But as I’ve looked back and mapped the journey, I see that this place and time made a HUGE impression on my beliefs, ethics and loyalties, for better and worse.
DISCLAIMER: Some Guardrails
Fraternities are based on trust and a level of secrecy and discretion. So for this post, I won’t name names in any matter that might shade someone’s reputation. Like when XXXXXXXXXXXXX and XXXXXXXXXXXXXer brought XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX to the house along with some XXXXXXXXX XXXXXXX and XXXXXXX until XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXXXX Oh, man. That was a night!
Another disclaimer: I also shared some drafts of this piece with a few KS brothers. Some of their feedback led to edits. My choice.
The Best Friends You Can Buy for $75
That was the what a semester’s dues was back then, including a cut for Nationals. It covered brotherhood and rituals, parties and beer. Yeah, sometimes we had to pass the hat, but our accounting-nerd CFOs could really stretch a beer dollar.
At JMU back then, Greek Row was on campus and governed by the university. The houses stretched along a walkway, uniform and dormitory-like, each housing 28 students. Several houses–two, three or four–connected into a single structure; Sig Ep was easily accessible through the fire door.
Each house had a communal room downstairs, maybe 1000-1200 square feet, with a small kitchen and a few side rooms for fraternal activities and storage. It was the kind of utilitarian space that you could hose down without worry and where the ceiling tiles were gone a month into every semester. There was raw wood wainscoting around the perimeter, topped with a drink ledge. The 3-tap bar and DJ booth were also wood, finished with some Kappa Sig branding.
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXand I painted several of the walls. We did a mural at the entrance to the room, a take on the Kappa Sigma rush poster: “The most wanted man on campus.” Another, spread across a 40-50 foot wall, was inspired by the label of Virginia Gentlemen, a local bourbon. It had a Colonial Virginia vibe and was pretty cool, I must say. I imagine it’s still there, buried behind 40 years of paint.
The Row backed up to the “shore” of Newman Lake, the burial site of countless couches, mattresses, several pairs of spent Vans, and likely a bit of evidence. Swimming was discouraged, though some souls were dispatched into the deep involuntarily.
We took our meals at the campus dining hall(s). Brothers, little sisters and pledges sat together at a few 10-top tables in one corner of D-hall. Most every meal featured plates of french fries for sharing. We were close to the milk dispenser. Further from the salad bar.
Why?
As a freshman, at 18, I felt like a loner, awkward. I didn’t mix well. I knew hardly anyone at JMU. I needed and wanted to break out of my shell. Joining a fraternity seemed like one way to do that.
In the summer before my freshman year, I worked with XXXXXXXXXX. He was Yogi Bear to my Captain Caveman at Kings Dominion. He talked up the fraternity life and invited me to visit the house when I got to campus for freshmen orientation. Seemed like nice guys, most all from Virginia and the mid-Atlantic. I “rushed” at other houses too. Each had a vibe but I felt most at home at Kappa Sig.
It was a fateful decision and I still question it 40 years later. College is the time to experiment and explore, to take risks and grow. I aspired to be creative, to push myself outside a comfort zone. To live a purposeful Beat life, whatever that meant.
On the surface, joining a fraternity seems anathema to that: I would travel in a pack, have a limited group of friends and connections and a more ritualized schedule. And free-thinking is not always a virtue in the cloistered cast of a fraternity.
At the time, my want for acceptance and belonging outweighed all that. I wanted Animal House.
“Chug, Pledge!”
I juggled a lot that first semester, living away from home and adjusting to new freedoms and myriad temptations. Oh right, and school, aka, academics. My first-semester’s 2.3 GPA wasn’t something to be proud of. Pledging a fraternity demands a lot of time and focus, and it’s a damn sexy mistress for a geeky teenager. My Dad seemed okay with the trade-off.
Hell Night
At the end of pledging comes Hell Night. It’s had plenty of portrayals in popular culture and, occasionally, in tragic news stories. We pledges had no idea what to expect. None. Just check your inhibitions at the door. Do what you are told.
I had the time of my life. Gonna try to be discreet here. There was alcohol, chanting and singing, screaming, mild hazing and humiliation, a dip in an ice-cold stream, more alcohol, friends and brothers, little sisters, nudity, autographs signed on various anatomies, Polaroids, nipples and peanut butter. And a whole lot of laughing, hugging and a few bruises. Like emerging from a cocoon, it was revelatory.
Stardusters
There were young women who liked us enough to want to be little sisters, an auxiliary chapter to the fraternity chapter. They were called Stardusters, after a song penned by brother Hoagie Carmichael (Beta-Theta, Indiana U., 1925). This was a spirited bunch, staunchly loyal to the brotherhood, and really more like family (I never had sisters). They were ever-present at meals and gatherings, they planned parties and cheered on brothers. They also kept the otherwise-unbridled Paco Rabanne-drenched-machismo from becoming too suffocating.
I’m not supposed to say it in these woke days, but they were some hotties. And they could hold their drink better than a lot of brothers.
Anyway, everything they witnessed and contributed to during these days prepared them for anything the world–especially men–would throw at them. Sadly, the national office disbanded all Starduster chapters in the late 80s, for liability reasons. It wasn’t entirely successful.
Culture/Politics
There was no cable TV in the house or phone service beyond intra-campus lines. Obviously, no wifi or internet. Internet? No one owned a computer yet. Or a personal phone.
This was Virginia in the mid-80s. South of the Mason-Dixon in Appalachia. JMU was well-integrated by then, I believe, but it wouldn’t resemble a patchwork from a distance.
The makeup of the chapter was largely from areas within a 2-4 hour drive of Harrisonburg, some from rural climes, lots of suburban kids, and a few city boys thrown in. Preppies, Parrot Heads, a punk or two, some early grungers and stoners, cheerleaders and dream boats, a few academic types. Majors ran the liberal arts gamut: Poli-sci, finance, econ and accounting, business management and marketing, a couple of English majors. Pre-law, pre-med, pre-CIA. Pre-elected-office. We excelled in sports and partying but self-sabotaged at Greek Sing and philanthropy.
More important than all that diversity, there were disparate beliefs and opinions among the brotherhood, sometimes expressed vigorously.
Note: The next paragraph I’ve altered, based on feedback from brothers who I asked to give this post a look. Suffice to say, the story behind the story touched some nerves. And writing it gave me some humbling clarity, even if I am deleting it here. My choice.
I’ll cut to the quick: in the mid-1980s, no men of color were pledged or initiated into the chapter. The by-laws did not require a majority to rule on such things, just a small number in opposition to a candidate. There were heated debates and some enraged, disgusted brothers on both sides. I knew it wasn’t right. I know others felt the same. But I went along. That’s hard and it stays with me.
No one was really “out” back then. This was just as AIDS erupted, though JMU was not affected, as far as any of us knew. Despite rumors and innuendos, the so-called “don’t ask, don’t tell” rule was evident in the chapter. Why two topics in quotation marks for this paragraph? It is what it is.
Okay, back to our regularly scheduled debauchery.
There were also the politics of partying, and of beer in particular. We had 5-7 kegs on a typical weekend party night. The cheapest was Goebel; we opted for a French pronunciation, a soft G with emphasis on the second syllable. Joe-belle. At some point, Schlitz Malt Liquor started pouring through the taps with greater frequency. It was a little more expensive but a lot more intoxicating. It really did a number on one’s GI system. Rough nights, rough mornings.
When the topic was debated at a Sunday meeting, concerns over health–and the negative impact on female attendance–were key. Finally, XXXXXXXXXXXXX took to the floor and proclaimed: “We do not drink beer for thirst or taste! We drink beer to get drunk!” It was a Patrick Henry moment. Schlitz would remain in the taps.
Parties
Blah blah brotherhood blah blah. Let’s get to the meat.
Our style of party was dark, crowded, hot, sticky and messy. Loud. Stale beer and other dubious fluids had permeated the linoleum floor and wooden wainscoting for years. So at every party, those latent, stanky molecules reactivated and spun airborne to shroud us all in an immersive, sweating scratch-n-sniff. A lot of history.
I credit our in-house professional DJs for creating a party trajectory throughout the night and making our parties feel unique on the row. Start with some crowd favorites and classics (U2, Bon Jovi, Icicle Works, Van Morrison, Lynyrd Skynyrd), then pop and dance (Madonna, New Order, Michael Jackson, Buffett, beach music), then some sexy funk (Prince, Kurtis Blow, Cameo). I’ve just been informed by one of said DJs that the mix was “more nuanced” than my depiction and that they were “artists.” Can’t argue.
The weekly schedule
Forget Sunday and Monday nights. They were for academics, healing and reflection. Okay.
On random Tuesdays, we’d summon the current pledge class to the house and challenge them to make a party: get girls, now. Go door to door if you have to. Get some beer too. A lot. Wednesdays were reserved for hanging at JM’s, a bar across from campus where our DJ brothers DJ’d. Thursday was Ladies Night at the house. Sounds classy. Friday and Saturday were generic parties at the house, depending on the season.
A few times a year, we’d host more exclusive, “proprietary” themed parties, in partnership with a sorority. Yeah, keep reading.

Pimp and Whore
I’m shocked just writing that now, but it was a damn good party back in the 80s. Sorority women dressed as, well, yeah, and the guys tricked out as, okay, you get it. On entry, the guys received $1000 in play money. The object of the affair was for the ladies to make as much money as possible, through whatever means. And yes, every year, sororities clamored to partner with us. Btw, I designed and printed the money, so my conscience is still conflicted (plus, I skimmed).
Casino Night
We actually splurged for real booze for this one. It was a classier vibe, with cocktail dresses and gowns and tuxedos, a la James Bond, if James Bond lived off the interstate in the Shenandoah Valley. I’d like to say that proceeds went to charity.
Playboy Mansion
Guys in pajamas and smoking jackets, girls in Bunny attire and lingerie. I know, right? One year XXXXXXXXXXX and I made name tags ID’ing ourselves as “Official Bunny Tasters.” Surprisingly, it worked almost too well. It was the 80s. And it was pretty innocent, really. Really? Yes. Yes? I said, yes. Okay!
Bonus
We had wine and cheese mixers during rush. Cheap jugs and cheddar, but with better plastic cups and plates. Each semester, the pledge class was responsible to design a theme party. My class did a Titanic theme. The tag: “be the first to go down with the ship.” We also had formals every winter, usually at a nice hotel near D.C. or Richmond. Or on a boat in the Chesapeake. Ask XXXXXXXXXXXXXX and XXXXXXXXXXX how they liked that one.
Oh, and Belinda and Charlotte from The GoGos came to a party at our house after a Saturday concert on campus. It was a scene. A few of us whisked them up to XXXXXXXXXXXX andXXXXXXXXXXXXXX’s‘s room, 202. We made extremely lame chitchat for about 20 minutes, until someone, mercifully, pulled the fire alarm to flush them out. They escaped through the SigEp fire door.
Bonus ++
A few times each semester, a character named G. Fred McDude would make an appearance at a party. His headshot was on our annual composite, so technically he was a brother, even an officer. G. Fred was indeed a brother, wearing a rubber mask and nothing else, save for a layer of strategically placed shaving cream. He’d streak through the crowd, accost a few folks, dance and leave. Any questions before we move on?
Also, a few times a semester, a party would devolve into water sports. The hoses came out and the party room was flooded with a few inches of hot water. Brothers and a few brave little sisters would take turns running down the hall, sliding across the floor (standing or belly-flopped) and crashing into the opposite wall. Or each other. Most of the folks were moderately clad, others not.
Any night might continue upstairs, elsewhere, or across the interstate at Howard Johnson’s for a Breakfast Grand Slam. After sun-up came the walks of shame, the hair of the dog and the boisterous sharing of sordid tales. And commiserating about the gastro-effects of malt liquor.
Takeaway
Might sound lofty, but I feel like I became a man and a leader in those four years. I certainly became more confident and strong of will from the experience. Like I said, some of my best friends and memories were made there. Even though those friends live a thousand miles away, I feel close to them; we’re meeting up more often in our imminent dotage.
We took care of each other, watched out for each other, got brothers and little sisters home safely. Encouraged everyone’s success. Celebrated and challenged them. And pranked them whenever applicable and deserved. Which was often.
“The Breakfast Club” came out during this period, in 1985. If you did a mashup of that with “Animal House” we’re getting really close, somewhere between Otis Day’s “Shout” and Simple Minds’ “Don’t You Forget About Me.” Apt.
In Club Speak: We weren’t woke. We were rednecks and reprobates, athletes and scholars, pretty boys and beer-bellied sloths, loners, lovers and a naked guy in a rubber mask.. Reckless and respectable. If you judge us by our behavior back then, be sure to apply the lens of the cultural zeitgeist of the 80s, when hair was big, jeans were tight, sex sold and greed was good. It might feel toxic in hindsight; we’ve come a long way.
Even though I was an English major, I used Google to confirm this quote from William Blake. “The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom.” There were excesses and indiscretions, no doubt. I think those paved the way–eventually–for richer insights and empathy, and a greater willingness to adapt to the world as it evolves. Life was big and still is. The palace still looms on the horizon.
Was it the right place for me? Doesn’t matter. It made me who I am: the mostly good, the righteously bad and the pompously ugly.







































































































































































